No, Facebook Did Not Panic and Shut Down an AI Program That Was Getting Dangerously Smart. In recent weeks, a story about experimental Facebook machine learning research has been circulating with increasingly panicky, Skynet esque headlines. Facebook engineers panic, pull plug on AI after bots develop their own language, one site wrote. Facebook shuts down down AI after it invents its own creepy language, another added. Did we humans just create Frankenstein asked yet another. One British tabloid quoted a robotics professor saying the incident showed the dangers of deferring to artificial intelligence and could be lethal if similar tech was injected into military robots. Starting Friday, anyone with a New York Public Library or Brooklyn Public Library will be able to stream thousands of awesome movies, including the entire Criterion. Tabtight professional, free when you need it, VPN service. Examples Of Public Domain Software. Free Program New Play Control Chibi Robo English Patch' title='Free Program New Play Control Chibi Robo English Patch' />References to the coming robot revolution, killer droids, malicious AIs and human extermination abounded, some more or less serious than others. Continually quoted was this passage, in which two Facebook chat bots had learned to talk to each other in what is admittedly a pretty creepy way. Bob I can i i everything else. Fifa 12 Pc Performance Patch. Alice balls have zero to me to me to me to me to me to me to me to me to Bob you i everything else. Alice balls have a ball to me to me to me to me to me to me to me to me. The reality is somewhat more prosaic. A few weeks ago, Fast. Co Design did report on a Facebook effort to develop a generative adversarial network for the purpose of developing negotiation software. The two bots quoted in the above passage were designed, as explained in a Facebook Artificial Intelligence Research unit blog post in June, for the purpose of showing it is possible for dialog agents with differing goals implemented as end to end trained neural networks to engage in start to finish negotiations with other bots or people while arriving at common decisions or outcomes. The bots were never doing anything more nefarious than discussing with each other how to split an array of given items represented in the user interface as innocuous objects like books, hats, and balls into a mutually agreeable split. The intent was to develop a chatbot which could learn from human interaction to negotiate deals with an end user so fluently said user would not realize they are talking with a robot, which FAIR said was a success The performance of FAIRs best negotiation agent, which makes use of reinforcement learning and dialog rollouts, matched that of human negotiators. FAIRs bots not only can speak English but also think intelligently about what to say. When Facebook directed two of these semi intelligent bots to talk to each other, Fast. Co reported, the programmers realized they had made an error by not incentivizing the chatbots to communicate according to human comprehensible rules of the English language. In their attempts to learn from each other, the bots thus began chatting back and forth in a derived shorthandbut while it might look creepy, thats all it was. Agents will drift off understandable language and invent codewords for themselves, FAIR visiting researcher Dhruv Batra said. Like if I say the five times, you interpret that to mean I want five copies of this item. This isnt so different from the way communities of humans create shorthands. Download Air Force Retirement Program Template Software. Facebook did indeed shut down the conversation, but not because they were panicked they had untethered a potential Skynet. FAIR researcher Mike Lewis told Fast. Co they had simply decided our interest was having bots who could talk to people, not efficiently to each other, and thus opted to require them to write to each other legibly. But in a game of content telephone not all that different from what the chat bots were doing, this story evolved from a measured look at the potential short term implications of machine learning technology to thinly veiled doomsaying. There are probably good reasons not to let intelligent machines develop their own language which humans would not be able to meaningfully understandbut again, this is a relatively mundane phenomena which arises when you take two machine learning devices and let them learn off each other. Its worth noting that when the bots shorthand is explained, the resulting conversation was both understandable and not nearly as creepy as it seemed before. As Fast. Co noted, its possible this kind of machine learning could allow smart devices or systems to communicate with each other more efficiently. Those gains might come with some problemsimagine how difficult it might be to debug such a system that goes wrongbut it is quite different from unleashing machine intelligence from human control. In this case, the only thing the chatbots were capable of doing was coming up with a more efficient way to trade each others balls. There are good uses of machine learning technology, like improved medical diagnostics, and potentially very bad ones, like riot prediction software police could use to justify cracking down on protests. All of them are essentially ways to compile and analyze large amounts of data, and so far the risks mainly have to do with how humans choose to distribute and wield that power. Hopefully humans will also be smart enough not to plug experimental machine learning programs into something very dangerous, like an army of laser toting androids or a nuclear reactor. But if someone does and a disaster ensues, it would be the result of human negligence and stupidity, not because the robots had a philosophical revelation about how bad humans are. At least not yet. Machine learning is nowhere close to true AI, just humanitys initial fumbling with the technology. If anyone should be panicking about this news in 2. In the New Harley Quinn and Batman Comic, Classic Harley Gets an Important, Modern Update. Though the Batman and Harley Quinn animated movie and its tie in comics are brand new, everything about them, from their visual aesthetic to the tone of their dialogue, feels as if they were plucked right out of Batman The Animated Series. That fact alone made at least the first issue of the comics series fun to dive into from the beginning, but Batman and Harley Quinn really stands out in the grander scheme of Harley centric stories by blending Harleys classic aesthetic with a voice much more in line with the person she is today. When we first met Harley 2. Batman mythos. Though she was introduced as such, Harleys always been so much more than the Jokers accomplice cum love interest. While weve never been given a straight answer as to why the Joker became the chaotic foil to Batmans fastidiousness, Harleys origins have always been deeply rooted in choice. Harley chose to free the Joker from Arkham and join him in his never ending campaign to terrorize Gotham and kill Batman. No matter how many times she may land behind bars or get locked up in Arkham herself, its almost always been understood that Harley knows she could just give up her life of crime and leave the Joker and his antics behind. As insane as Harley often seems, shes slipped back into a more sensible modality enough times that you get the sense that shes much more in control of herself than she lets on. Its that part of her character thats always made her relationship with the Jokerwhich is objectively abusive and toxicsomewhat difficult to stomach. Harley loves her Puddin, yes, but more often than not, that loves been unrequited and caused Harley an inordinate amount of pain and difficulty. It took Harleys comic book counterparts nearly 3. Batman and Harley Quinns take on the character begins. During one of their rather routine outings committing hot sauce related crimes, Harley and the Joker are interrupted by Batman, Nightwing, and a number of technical difficulties. Every weapon that the Joker tries to use against Gothams finest backfires and Harley can barely contain her fits of laughter at the sight of him. As Harley and the Joker run to make their escape in a Joker shaped hot air balloon, the Joker quickly informs Harley that theres only room for one, but when he attempts to make a go for the ride himself, hes shocked to find that its been untethered, leaving him stranded. Without hesitation, Harley tells the Joker directly that all of the nights problemsthe destruction of his Joker mecha, his backfiring gunswere all her doing as revenge for not paying her enough attention. As much as Harley does for the Joker, she explains, the only person he seems capable of caring about is Batman. Harleys getting back at the Joker ends with the clown prince of crime being hauled off by Gotham PD, much to the astonishment of Batman and Nightwing, but given that this is a series about Harley teaming up with Bats, the ending isnt all that surprising. Compared to a number of the other things that the Jokers done to Harley over the years, his insensitivity toward her feelings in Harley Quinn and Batman is one of his lesser offenses. But the very fact that his callousness toward her is enough to set her off is what makes Quinns characterization in this telling stand out. Rather than waiting around for the Joker to put her life in mortal danger again or to play more mind games with her, Harley decides that shes fed up with his shit and just decides to do her own thing. Simple a choice as it may seem, its a move that we never really got to see Harley make for herself during The Animated Series, where her solo career was precipitated by the Joker choosing to kick her out of his gang. Harleys always had a power and agency within herself thats simmering just beneath the surface of her classic characterization. Here, though, its bubbling over in the best possible way.